Supermassive Black Holes (BHs) seem to be ubiquitous in the center of spheroids - elliptical galaxies and bulges of spirals. The tight empirical correlations of the mass of the central BH with the global properties of the host galaxy spheroid (stellar velocity dispersion sigma, mass, and luminosity) indicate a close connection between galaxy formation and nuclear activity in Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs), a phase in the evolution of galaxies during which the supermassive BH is actively growing through accretion. Several unified formation scenarios have been proposed in which AGN feedback plays an important role by suppressing star formation in massive galaxies. Studying the evolution with redshift of the BH mass scaling relations provides important insights into their origin. Combining HST imaging and Keck spectroscopy of a sample of 40 Seyfert-1 galaxies at z~0.4 and z~0.6, we simultaneously study the evolution of the BH mass - sigma and BH mass - bulge luminosity relations. I will focus on the latter, for which we include a sample of 44 quasars out to z=4.5 taken from literature, with spheroid luminosity and BH mass corrected to a self-consistent calibration, and thereby extend the BH mass range to over two orders of magnitude. Correcting spheroid luminosity for passive evolution and taking into account selection effects, we determine that at fixed present-day V-band luminosity, MBH/L_sph ~ (1+z)^(1.4+/-0.2). This evolutionary trend suggests that BH growth precedes spheroid assembly. Interestingly, the BH mass - total host galaxy luminosity relation is apparently non-evolving. It hints at either a more fundamental relation or that the spheroid grows by a redistribution of stars. I will also present first results of an ongoing project that uses Keck longslit spectra of a sample of 100 Seyfert-1 galaxies in the local Universe to (i) create a robust local baseline for the BH mass - sigma relation and (ii) measure the likely degree of rotational support when obtaining the "global" dispersion from unresolved data of our distant galaxies or from SDSS 3'' fiber spectra.
In the first part of this talk, I will review the current state of affairs
in the study of cluster formation at high redshift. Topics will include
the observational and theoretical evidence for galaxy structures
associated with luminous quasars at z~6, overdensities of Lyman break and
Lya-emitting galaxies at 3
We present results from a detailed study of cluster red sequence at z~1
from the ACS Intermediate Redshift Cluster Survey (Mei et al. 2009). Our
analysis shows that the red sequence is well defined at these redshifts
and elliptical and lenticular galaxies lie on similar color-magnitude
relations. We analyze the parameters of the early-type color-magnitude
relations - scatter, slope and zero-point - as a function of redshift,
galaxy properties and cluster mass.
Roughly half of the red elliptical galaxies observed today have
formed since z=1. I will present galaxy clustering results from the
DEEP2 Redshift Survey that strongly constrain the mechanism
responsible for the quenching or cessation of star formation in
these galaxies. I will show where this quenching is occurring on
large scales and how it can not be due primarily to cluster-specific
physics. I will also present results on the clustering of opticallybright
quasars and X-ray selected AGN at z=1. I will show new
results on the prevalence of outflowing galactic winds at z=1 and
discuss their role in quenching star formation. Finally, I will
present a new wide-area prism survey that will allow further
studies of galaxy evolution to z=1 with the largest faint galaxy
survey to date.
The Cold Dark Matter (CDM) paradigm is very successful at explaining the growth of structure on large scales. However, it predicts an excess of structure on sub-galactic scales. Motivated by this discrepancy, we ask the question if dark galaxies (or dim dwarf galaxies) can be found by their tidal gravitational effect on the gas disks of galaxies. I will focus most of this talk on my recent work (Chakrabarti & Blitz 2009) on an analysis of the observed perturbations on the outskirts of the gas disk of the Milky Way to infer and characterize a dark sub-halo that tidally interacted with our galaxy. By comparing the Fourier modes from a large set of high resolution Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics simulations of a Milky Way like galaxy tidally interacting with dark sub-halos, I showed that the best fit to the observations is produced by a 1:100 satellite with a pericentric approach distance of ~ 5kpc. I will also demonstrate a fundamental property of parabolic orbits that allows us to break the degeneracy between the mass and distance cubed in the tidal force. Next, I will show preliminary results that allow us to extend this tidal analysis method to characterize perturbers in generality. Finally, I will end by discussing results from radiative transfer calculations performed with my code RADISHE, that allow us to study the effects of tidal interactions on the emergent infrared SED and images of simulated galaxies.
Gravitational lensing by galaxy clusters was predicted in the 1930s, and finally discovered in 1980s. Since these initial discoveries, several dozen significant cluster lenses have been found. Lensing clusters probe the distribution of massive haloes in the universe; the expected arc production frequency can be predicted from simulations and compared to existing data. Massive lensing clusters act as 'natural telescopes', providing highly magnified images of background sources which cannot otherwise be studied using the current generation of telescopes. The details of the observed lensing in clusters also probes the internal properties of these massive haloes. Most cluster strong lens studies to date have been limited by the small number and heterogeneous nature of the sample of known lenses (most of which are one-off discoveries). I will report on efforts to take the study of strong lensing clusters to a new statistical regime, by identifying and studying two new samples of strong lenses within large catalogs of optically selected galaxy clusters from the RCS-2 and SDSS surveys; in total we have found hundreds of new giant arcs. These efforts are now approximately three-quarters-complete; in this progress report I will describe some of the successes of these studies, and the remaining challenges.
I will present results from a study of proto-globular cluster candidates in the interacting galaxy system Arp 284 (NGC 7714/5). Studies of the Antennae and M51 have suggested that the majority of young massive star clusters dissipate in ~20 Myr due to mass loss. The time scale and mass dependence of this effect are still controversial, due in part to the complex star formation histories of these systems. Arp 284 is at a much earlier stage in its interaction, making the star formation history somewhat simpler. We search for the dissolution effect using cluster colors obtained from archival HST data and estimate ages for over 150 clusters using evolutionary synthesis models. We find that clusters in NGC 7714 are generally less than 20 Myr old, while the bridge between the two galaxies may host an older population. However, the significance of these results is uncertain due to observational limitations.
Recent advances in ground and space based near-infrared imaging
are giving us the first glimpses of galaxy formation in the early
universe. However, considerable uncertainty remains in how these
objects are formed and what their present day counterparts are. I
will begin by outlining what we know about the universe when it
was ~1/3 its present age (z~2) and what constraints this places on
the process of galaxy formation at higher redshift. Then, using
multi- wavelength data and deep spectroscopy from the 10m Keck
telescopes I will show that the number and mass of galaxies
appears to be growing rapidly between 400 million and 1.5 billion
years after the big bang (4
Over the past five years, searches in Sloan Digital Sky Survey data
have more than doubled the number of known satellite galaxies
orbiting around the Milky Way disk,revealing a population of
ultra-faint systems with total light output barely reaching ~1000
times that of the Sun. These newly-discovered dwarf galaxies
represent galaxy formation in the extreme. They are not only the
faintest galactic systems known but they are also the most dark
matter dominated and most metal poor galaxies in the universe.
Completeness corrections suggest that we are poised on the
edge of a vast discovery space in galaxy phenomenology, with
hundreds more ultra-faint galaxies to be discovered as future
instruments hunt for the low-luminosity threshold of galaxy
formation. I discuss how dark matter dominated dwarfs of this
kind probe the small-scale power- spectrum and offer a particularly
useful target for dark matter indirect detection experiments.
Galaxy clusters are the most massive virialised structures in the
Universe. Their number density depends on both the geometry of the
Universe and the rate at which structure grows.
Galaxy clusters are also rich in relatively dust-free, early-type
galaxies, which are known to host only Type Ia supernovae. Evidence from
several surveys now suggest that Type Ia supernovae hosted by early-type galaxies
are better standard candles than Type Ia supernovae hosted by galaxies of
other types.
In this talk I will describe how clusters can be used as a dark energy
probe, both through the number density of clusters and the through the
Type Ia supernovae that can be found in them.
The aim of this talk is to discuss the physical, structural and evolutionary properties of early-type galaxies (ETG). Strong size evolution of ETG between z?1.5 and the present has been reported by several authors. On the other hand, stellar populations of these massive ETG appear to evolve only passively since then. The role of the environment in both processes remains poorly understood. Here we present a new study in which we derive stellar masses, ages, star formation histories (SFH) and sizes of massive ETG in high-density environments at z~1.3 (RDCS1252, Lynx-E, Lynx-W) and compare them with those measured in similarly mass-selected samples of contemporaries in low-density environment (GOODS). Robust estimates of these parameters are obtained by sampling the entire relevant domain of emission of the different stellar populations, from rest-frame UV to NIR. Sizes are measured from deep ACS data available in all environments. We find that a fraction of ETG in the field employs longer timescales to assemble their mass than their cluster contemporaries. Hence we conclude that, while the formation epoch of early-types only depends on their masses (downsizing), the environment does regulate the timescales of their SFH. We also find that the evolution in size at fixed mass both in the cluster and in the field between z = 1.3 and the present is a factor of 2. A combination of structural evolution of individual galaxies through the accretion of companions and the continuous formation of ETG through increasingly gas-poor mergers is one plausible explanation of our observations.
The star formation rates (SFRs) of Lyman Break Galaxies (LBGs) are typically
estimated based on their UV properties or mid-IR photometry using local
relations that are assumed to be true at high redshift (eg. reddening laws, IR
SEDs). Recently, several lensed LBGs have been discovered with large
magnifications allowing detailed infrared studies of this otherwise
unobservable population. I'll present the Spitzer mid-IR spectra and mid- to
far-IR
photometry of two lensed LBGs, cB58 and the "Cosmic Eye." With these data we
can test whether or not these locally determined relations are valid for high
redshift starbursts.
This talk introduces the Multi-wavelength Extreme Starburst Sample (MESS), a new catalog of 138 star-forming galaxies (0.1 < z < 0.3) optically selected from SDSS using emission line strength diagnostics to have SFR > 50 solar masses per year. The MESS is designed to complement other existing samples of starburst galaxies, such as the luminous infrared galaxies (LIRGs), commonly selected from wide area infrared and submillimeter surveys. Observations using the multiband imaging photometer (MIPS; 24, 70 and 160 micron channels) on the Spitzer Space Telescope have been completed. These data combined with visible, near-IR, and radio observations are providing new insight into the LIRG and ULIRG phenomenon. In terms of optical properties, the MESS span the range between the ``blue cloud'' and the red sequence. It is thought that dust obscuration plays an important role in a possible evolutionary process connecting LIRGS, ULIRGs, E+A galaxies, and for
those objects containing AGN, QSOs. The selection criterion for the MESS suggests they may be less obscured than typical ULIRGs or LIRGs, making them possible candidates for a link between the latter and E+A galaxies. We discuss this relationship between the MESS and samples selected through alternative criteria in terms of their spectroscopic, and visible through far-infrared mophological properties; and attempt to place them in this sequence. Early imaging results in K-band also indicate an intriguing number of disturbed morphologies.
Triton is one of the few bodies in the solar system with observed
cryo-volcanic activity, in the form of plumes (Soderblom et al. 1990).
Prompted by evidence from previous observations at ground and
space-based telescopes of possible seasonal surface changes on Triton
(Young & Stern 1999), we proposed to confirm and characterize these
changes using the HST ACS instrument to image Triton at UV, B, V, I and
Methane-band wavelengths over as much of its surface as visible from
near Earth in 2005. Preliminary analysis indicates a rotation light
curve amplitude in excess of that predicted by static models (Hillier
et al. 1994 & Hillier 1999) for visual wavelengths, and significant
departures from observations taken 12 years earlier in the UV. We will
describe in detail these differences which set constraints on activity
and surface temperature as well as composition. Such constraints have
profound implications for our understanding of Triton's evolution as
well as the history of other outer solar system bodies that may undergo
similar geophysical processes or have similar composition, such as
Pluto (Buratti et al. 2003, Young et al. 2001).
References
As impressively as Lambda-CDM simulations appear to reproduce the large scale structure of the universe, comparisons on smaller scales have so far proven less convincing. Detailed comparisons on galaxy cluster scales are now within reach, but our analysis methods have been lacking in two ways. Strong lens modeling techniques have been unable to fully process the large numbers of multiple images revealed in recent deep multiband ACS observations. We discuss how this problem has been overcome, resulting in more accurate and detailed mass maps than those attainable previously. In particular, we present our Abell 1689 massmap, the only to perfectly reproduce all the observed strong lensing features. At this point our second shortcoming becomes apparent. It is unclear how best to extract the information contained in such a detailed, minimal-assumption mass map! Many previous analyses have focused on measuring the radial profiles and central concentrations of their mass models. A few others have placed modest constraints on galaxy halo truncation radii. We discuss the feasibility of obtaining new physical measurements such as the substructure mass function and the degree to which light traces mass.
Supernovae (SNe) near maximum brightness provide excellent
opportunities to study galactic and individual stellar processes out
to high redshift. However, Type II core-collapse SNe detections have
been limited to z < 0.7 because of the inherent properties of most SNe
and the capabilities of current facilities. Type IIn supernovae (SNe
IIn) result from the death of the most massive stars. The exceptional
properties of SNe IIn render them easier to detect at high redshift
than other SN types. I will discuss our method to detect 0.8 < z <
2.2 SNe IIn in the CFHTLS Deep survey and present compelling
photometric candidates. I will show "hot-off-the-press" Keck
spectroscopy that has already confirmed two of the highest redshift
Type II SNe to date. In addition to their bright outburst, SNe IIn
produce extremely bright emission lines in their spectra that remain
bright for years after outburst and are detectable to z ~ 3 using
current 8m-class telescopes. Detection and evolution of these lines
can be used to confirm high redshift SNe IIn and measure their
energies. I will discuss the implications of the data on
high-redshift stellar and galactic processes such as the SN IIn and
Type II supernova rates, the universal star formation rate, and galaxy
IMF evolution. I will conclude by addressing future programs to
detect and spectroscopically confirm 2 < z < 6 SNe IIn that capitalize
on the sensitivity of future facilities such as the LSST and TMT
Black holes are not only an integral component of galaxies, but they
also appear to have played a fundamental role in galaxy evolution. It
is theorized that galaxy-scale feedback from high-redshift quasars is
key to understanding the properties of the most massive galaxies
today. However, direct observations of the feedback have been lacking.
Our observations on the extended nebulae around low-redshift quasars
show that recent quasar-driven superwinds have drastically altered
their environments. The superwind is capable of ejecting most of the
interstellar medium to large distances, demonstrating an efficient
mechanism that can regulate both star formation and black hole growth.
Such superwinds provide local analogs of the quasar feedback
hypothesized to have happened in the early universe.
What is Dark Energy? Dark Matter? How did galaxies and Supermassive Black
Holes (SMBH) form and evolve in the early universe? What is the origin of stars, planets and life itself? Answers to these and related questions will require space-based and ground-based astronomy coupled with experimental and
theoretical physics. Current ground-based 8-10m optical telescopes like Keck
and Gemini are helping, but it is becoming increasingly clear that we must push to much fainter sources with much better data in order to make significant
advances on many of the key problems. The Thirty Meter Telescope (TMT)
project will provide diffraction limited and seeing limited capabilities that will be highly synergistic with facilities like the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) and the Atacama Large Millimeter Array (ALMA) and other planned astronomy missions. The scientific drivers for TMT, and how they lead to the overall system requirements and design will be described in this presentation.
In the past decade, ground and space-based observations of high
redshift galaxies (z>4) have begun to outline the process of galaxy
assembly, but its details remain poorly constrained. In one scenario,
the most massive galaxies assemble earlier than their less massive
counterparts, while in another, large numbers of low-luminosity dwarf
galaxies dominate these earlier times. There is presently little
information on the structure and the star-formation process of these
high redshift galaxies.
I present results from two complimentary studies in the Hubble Ultra
Deep Field (HUDF) to understand the properties of these high redshift
galaxies. The HUDF contains significant numbers of B, V and i-band
dropout objects. These galaxies are too faint individually to
accurately measure their radial surface brightness profiles. I
separately co-add V, i and z-band HUDF images of sets of z=4,5,6
objects, pre-selected to have nearly identical compact sizes and the
roundest shapes. I generate average surface brightness profiles from
the composite images. Results show that even the faintest z=4-6
galaxies are resolved and the inner profiles are best fit by Sersic
profiles with Sersic index n<2.
Using low-resolution spectroscopy of Grism ACS Program for
Extragalactic Science (GRAPES), 47 Lyman Break Galaxies at z=5-6 are
confirmed in the HUDF. For these 47 galaxies, I find that the UV
spectral slope shows that the galaxies at z=5-6 are less dusty
compared to galaxies at z=3 and the peak star formation intensity (SFR
per unit area) does not vary significantly from the local universe to
z=5-6. The constancy of this peak intensity implies that the same
physical mechanism limits starburst intensity at all redshifts up to
z=6.
While gravity plays a major role and is responsible for the assembly of
matter into large structures, more complicated, non-gravitational
physical processes have also contributed in a significant manner to
shape the observed properties of galaxies and clusters of galaxies. In
spite of the enormous progress made in the last decade, still the
details of the formation and evolution of galaxies and clusters are not
well understood. Answers can be found by studying the properties of such
structures at early times (z>~1) in the history of the universe, when
most of these objects begin to form and the surrounding environment
begins to be established. Using the Advanced Camera for Surveys on the
Hubble Space Telescope and the ESO Very Large Telescope, supported
by other facilities, the dynamical properties of massive clusters at z~1
have been investigated in more detail, and a more closer look at the
properties of their galaxy populations have been obtained. This has allowed
us to shed more light on our understanding of how massive clusters of
galaxies in the local universe were put together during their early stages of
evolution, as well as the epoch and mode of formation of early-type
galaxies. I will present some of the most important results, together
with some preliminary ones, of this investigation and discuss their
implications on structure formation and evolution.
I plan to present current results from the ORELSE survey, an extensive multiwavelength study into the mechanisms that drive galaxy evolution in and around large-scale structures at high redshift. The first phase of the survey is a systematic search for structure on scales greater than 10 Mpc around 20 known galaxy clusters at redshifts of 0.6 < z < 1.3. When complete, the ORELSE survey will cover nearly 5 square degrees, all targeted at high-density regions, making it complementary to field surveys such as DEEP2 and COSMOS. I will describe the large-scale structures that have thus far been photometrically and spectroscopically confirmed and focus in particular on the Cl1604 supercluster at z = 0.9, which contains at least eight clusters and spans roughly 10 Mpc on the sky and 100 Mpc in depth. To date, the Cl1604 supercluster is the largest structure mapped at z~1, with the most constituent clusters and the largest number of spectroscopically confirmed member galaxies. I plan to describe the complex three-dimensional structure of the supercluster, the properties of its member galaxies as a function of environment, and the systemÕs large population of active galaxies detected through radio, mid-IR, and X-ray observations. After examining the optical properties of these galaxies, implications on AGN feedback as a possible mechanism to quench star formation and accelerate galaxy evolution within the system will also be discussed.
Much progress has been made in measuring black hole (BH) masses in (non-active)
galactic nuclei using the tight correlation between stellar velocity
dispersions (sigma) in galaxies and the mass of their central BH. The use of
this correlation in quasars, however, is hampered by the difficulty in
measuring sigma in host galaxies that tend to be overpowered by their very
bright nuclei. I discuss preliminary results from a project that focuses on
z~0.3 quasars suffering from heavy extinction at shorter wavelengths. This
makes it possible to obtain clean spectra of the hosts in the spectral regions
of interest, while broad lines (like H-alpha) are still visible at longer
wavelengths. We compare BH masses obtained from velocity dispersions to those
obtained from the BLR and thus probe the evolution of this relation and BH
growth with redshift and luminosity.
Understanding the formation and evolution of disk galaxies,
in particular the formation of their spheroidal (or bulge)
components, remains a challenge both from the theoretical and
observational perspectives. Originally thought to form through
dissipationless collapse or the violent merging of smaller
fragments at high-redshift, recent observations have challenged
these views suggesting ongoing star formation in galactic
bulges due, perhaps, to a redistribution of disk material from
the presence of a bar. From the observational point of view,
formation histories can be probed locally (fossil record) via
structural, dynamical, and stellar population trends, and
directly (formation in situ) by observations as a function of
lookback time. In this talk I will present results from
ongoing studies addressing both perspectives and discuss them
in the context of currently favored bulge formation scenarios.
Cosmic evolution of BH mass scaling relations
Vardha Nicola Bennert (UC Santa Barbara)
The Formation of Massive Galaxies and Galaxy Clusters in the Early Universe
Roderik Overzier (MPA)
Stellar populations and morphology on the red sequence at z~1
Simona Mei (University of Paris VII)
Clustering, Quenching, and Feedback: Galaxies and AGN at z=1
Alison Coil (UC San Diego)
Deciphering the Dynamical Impact of Cold Dark Matter Sub-Structure
Sukanya Chakrabarti (UC Berkeley)
Strong Lensing by Optically Selected Galaxy Clusters
Mike Gladders (University of Chicago)
Searching for Star Cluster Dissolution in the Interacting Galaxy System Arp 284
Brad Peterson (Iowa State University and IPAC)
Probing the formation of the first galaxies
Peter Capak (Caltech)
Dwarf Galaxies, Dark Matter, and the Threshold of Galaxy Formation
James Bullock (UC Irvine)
Using galaxy clusters as probes of dark energy
Chris Lidman (ESO)
Probing structural and stellar populations evolution out to the densest environments at z~1.3
Alessandro Rettura (JHU)
A Spitzer Study of Lensed Lyman Break Galaxies: Testing Star Formation
Diagnostics at High Redshift
Brian Siana (Caltech)
The Curious Case of the MESS Starburst Galaxies
Eddie Laag (UCR)
HST Photometry of Triton: Evidence for a Changing Surface in the Outer
Solar System
James Bauer (JPL/SSC/WISE)
Buratti, B.J., Hillier, J.K., Heinze, A.,Hicks, M.D., Tryka, K.A.,
Mosher, J.A., Ward, J., Garske, M., Young, J., & Atienza-Rosel, J.
Icarus, 162, 171.
Hillier, J., Veverka, J., Helfenstein, P., & Lee, P. 1994, Icarus, 109,
296.
Hillier, J.K. 1999, Icarus, 139, 202.
Soderblom, L.A., Becker, T.L., Kieffer, S.W., Brown, R.H., Hansen,
C.J., & Johnson, T.V. 1990, Science, 250, 410.
Young, L.A., & Stern, A.S. 1999, AJ, 122, 449.
Young, E. F.; Binzel, R. P.; Crane, K. 2001, AJ, 121, 552.
"Perfect" mass maps of galaxy cluster substructure and direct comparison to simulations
Dan Coe (Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Caltech)
The Detection of z ~ 2 Type IIn Supernovae: A New Window to
the High Redshift Universe
Jeff Cooke (UC Irvine)
Extended Emission-Line Regions: Remnants of Quasar Superwinds?
Hai Fu (Caltech)
TMT Science and Instruments
David Crampton (National Research Council, Canada)
Understanding the Nature of High Redshift Galaxies in the HUDF
Nimish Hathi (UCR)
Assembling dark matter and baryons in the young universe: probing
massive, gravitationally bound structures at redshift about unity
Ricardo Demarco (UCR)
Studying Galaxy Evolution in High Redshift Large-Scale Structures with the ORELSE Survey
Dale Kocevski (UCD)
Quasar Black Hole Masses from Velocity Dispersions
Gabriela Canalizo (UCR)
Galaxy Bulge Formation: Observational Perspectives
Lauren McArthur (Caltech)
The Redshift Evolution of Galactic Structures (Bars, Bulges &
Disks) at z < 1 from COSMOS: Quantifying the Assembly of the Hubble
Sequence
Kartik Sheth (Spitzer Science Center)